Last year, my friend Michele was going to take me to see Aerosmith. She had bought us VIP tickets for my birthday, and we were really looking forward to it.
Unfortunately, the concert was canceled, and I figured that opportunity had passed because Aerosmith wasn’t supposed to do any more concerts for health reasons (I mean, they are in their 70s, but you would never know it).
Then, almost a year later, right before my birthday, Aerosmith and friends were scheduled to perform at the Hollywood Bowl, and Michele scored us tickets.
Clair Levy and longtime friend Michele smiling together at the Hollywood Bowl during the Aerosmith and Friends concert.
It wasn’t the concert we’d originally planned. Performers including Billy Idol, the Wilson sisters from Heart, and the Black Crowes sang Aerosmith songs before Aerosmith came out to perform a few of their own. Dave Grohl from Foo Fighters even joined them on drums, which was particularly funny because Michele had produced a Foo Fighters documentary years earlier.
And you know what? We had a wonderful time.
We had a great dinner at the Hollywood Bowl, enjoyed the music, and I even struck up a conversation with a couple of people who worked in the defense industry. One seemed interested when I mentioned that I write executive resumes, so naturally, I got his number.
But the best part was spending the evening with Michele, whom I have been friends with since high school.
Looking back, it was an amazing evening, even though it wasn’t anything like the one we’d originally planned.
I’ve been thinking about that experience because it reminded me of something I see in career transitions.
Sometimes an opportunity doesn’t work out, and we assume that door has closed. But circumstances change, people make different decisions, and another opportunity can appear when we least expect it.
The question is whether we’re willing to consider it when it does.
When the Opportunity You Wanted Doesn’t Work Out
Think about the executive who spends months pursuing a particular position.
They’ve researched the company, met with the leadership team, and started imagining what it would be like to take on the role. Maybe it’s the promotion they’ve been working toward for years or an opportunity to move into a different industry.
Then they learn the company has selected someone else.
Career coach Marlo Lyons explores this in her Harvard Business Review article, Job Rejection Doesn’t Have to Sting. She recommends looking at what you can learn from the experience, including whether the position genuinely aligned with your priorities and what you might improve before your next interview.
Even when the decision has nothing to do with their qualifications, it still hurts. They’ve invested time and energy in the process, and they may have become attached to the future they imagined.
I once heard grief described as missing the future you thought you were going to have. That description has stayed with me. While losing a career opportunity is very different from losing someone you love, I think that observation still holds. Sometimes the disappointment goes beyond the opportunity itself. You’re also letting go of the future you’d already started imagining.
That can make it hard to recognize the possibilities that come along afterward. I’ve worked with professionals who become so focused on a particular title, company, or career direction that it’s difficult for them to consider something different.
I understand that. When you’ve spent years working toward a goal, changing direction can feel like giving up on something important.
But I think it helps to separate what you wanted from what you hoped that opportunity would give you.
Was it the title itself? The chance to lead a larger organization? Greater financial security? More influence over business decisions? An opportunity to work in an industry you care about?
Those distinctions matter because there may be more than one way to achieve what you’re looking for.
A Different Opportunity Deserves Its Own Evaluation
When Michele and I finally went to the Hollywood Bowl, we weren’t getting the original concert experience. We didn’t have the same VIP plans, and the performance was structured differently.
But I didn’t spend the evening comparing everything to what we might have experienced a year earlier.
I enjoyed what was actually happening.
I think that distinction offers a useful career lesson.
When a professional misses out on a particular opportunity, the next one may look different. Perhaps the company is smaller, the title isn’t quite what they expected, or the industry is unfamiliar.
That doesn’t automatically make it a lesser opportunity.
The U.S. Department of Labor’s CareerOneStop guidance on evaluating a job offer recommends considering factors beyond compensation, including whether the work is meaningful, the organization aligns with your values, and the position supports your long-term career goals.
Those are useful considerations when you’re deciding whether an unexpected opportunity deserves a closer look.
A smaller organization might offer broader decision-making authority. A lateral move could provide experience needed for a future executive position. A role outside someone’s traditional industry might introduce them to challenges that expand their leadership capabilities.
Of course, the opposite can also be true. A different opportunity might offer less responsibility, fewer resources, or limited advancement potential.
That’s why I wouldn’t encourage someone to accept an alternative simply because it’s available.
I’d encourage them to evaluate it based on what matters to them now.
Does the opportunity move you closer to the kind of work, responsibility, and professional life you want?
That’s a more useful question than whether it looks exactly like the position you originally hoped to get.
Don’t Underestimate the Relationships You’ve Built
Another part of my Aerosmith story matters.
Michele couldn’t get tickets at first because she was in the editing studio. The opportunity became available because someone she knew had tickets and decided not to use them.
If that friend hadn’t changed her plans, our evening at the Hollywood Bowl might never have happened.
It was fortunate timing, and it happened through a personal connection.
Professional opportunities can develop in similar ways.
A former colleague hears about an opening before it’s widely advertised. A hiring manager remembers someone who interviewed well for a previous position. A professional contact changes organizations and reaches out because they know someone with the experience their new company needs.
These situations aren’t guaranteed, and relationships shouldn’t be treated simply as a way to get something from someone.
But they illustrate why staying connected matters.
I’ve seen professionals put tremendous effort into submitting applications while spending relatively little time maintaining relationships with people who already know their work.
The U.S. Department of Labor’s CareerOneStop also emphasizes the importance of building professional connections during a job search, including reaching out to people who may know about opportunities that aren’t publicly advertised.
It’s a useful reminder that applying for positions is only one part of a job search. Maintaining relationships and having conversations with people who know your work deserve attention, too.
Those relationships can be especially valuable when a career opportunity doesn’t work out.
For example, if you’ve interviewed for a position and the company selects another candidate, there’s nothing wrong with thanking the hiring team and expressing continued interest in the organization. You could shoot them an email saying:
Dear [Hiring Manager’s Name],
I wanted to congratulate you and the team on filling the [Job Title] position. It was a pleasure learning more about [Company Name] and your work during the interview process.
While I am disappointed not to be joining the team at this time, I remain very interested in [Company Name] and the impact you are making in [industry or mission area]. Please keep my information on file for future opportunities where my background in [briefly mention key skill or area of expertise] might be a strong fit.
Thank you again for the opportunity to interview and for the professional, thoughtful experience. I wish your new hire and the entire team continued success.
You don’t need to repeatedly follow up or try to change their decision. A thoughtful message and an occasional relevant connection may be enough to keep the relationship open.
The same applies to former colleagues, managers, clients, and professional contacts.
You never know when someone’s circumstances will change or when they might think of you for something you hadn’t considered.
Sometimes Timing Changes the Opportunity
Another thing worth considering is how much can change in a year.
When our original Aerosmith concert was canceled, I had no reason to assume we’d have another chance to see them. We thought Aerosmith might never perform together again because of the band’s health issues. And when Michele couldn’t get tickets to the Hollywood Bowl show, it looked as though that opportunity might pass us by, too. Though at the time, I didn’t know this – she surprised me once she had the tickets.
Then circumstances changed.
In a professional setting, timing can significantly influence whether an opportunity works out.
A company may not have the budget to hire someone today. Six months later, it may have secured funding, acquired another business, or reorganized its leadership team.
An executive who wasn’t selected for one position might be a strong candidate for a different role after the organization’s needs change.
Your own circumstances may change, too.
Perhaps a role you would have accepted two years ago no longer makes sense because you’ve developed additional expertise or reconsidered your priorities.
That’s one reason I encourage professionals to revisit their career goals periodically, especially after a major transition.
An opportunity that wasn’t right before may become more relevant later. And something you once wanted may no longer be the best choice for you.
The important thing is to recognize when circumstances have changed enough to warrant another look.
What Can You Do When a Career Opportunity Falls Through?
It’s easy to talk about remaining open to second chances. It’s harder when you’ve just received a rejection, lost a position, or watched a long-anticipated opportunity disappear.
Instead of immediately pursuing the next available opening, I’d suggest taking time to understand what you were really hoping to gain.
Here are five questions worth considering:
- What made the original opportunity attractive?
Look beyond the title or company name. Identify the responsibilities, challenges, working environment, compensation, or growth potential that made you interested.
- Which of those priorities still matter?
Your goals may have changed since you first began pursuing the opportunity. Be clear about what remains important and where you’re willing to be flexible.
- What other opportunities could offer similar value?
Consider different organizations, industries, business models, or roles that might use your capabilities in ways you haven’t explored.
Compensation is another reason to evaluate an opportunity carefully rather than judging it by the job title alone. As I explain in Negotiating Your Worth: Sign-On Bonuses, Equity, and Profit Sharing, the overall financial value of an offer can extend beyond base salary. Understanding the complete package can help you make a more informed decision.
- Which relationships are worth maintaining?
Think about former colleagues, recruiters, hiring managers, mentors, and other professional contacts who know your work. Stay connected because you value the relationship, not solely because you’re looking for an opening.
- How will you evaluate the next opportunity?
Decide what would make a new position worthwhile. That might include greater responsibility, meaningful work, professional development, financial considerations, or the opportunity to make a measurable business contribution.
These questions won’t eliminate the disappointment of a missed opportunity, but they can help you make more deliberate decisions about what comes next.
You May Not Get the Same Opportunity Twice
I don’t want to suggest that every missed opportunity eventually comes back around.
Sometimes a position is filled, a company changes direction, or a career path becomes less realistic. There are opportunities we genuinely don’t get a second chance to pursue.
But missing out on something can also clarify what matters to us and help us recognize possibilities we might otherwise overlook.
Looking back on my evening at the Hollywood Bowl, I’m grateful that Michele was able to get those tickets.
We didn’t have the concert we’d originally planned, but we had a wonderful evening. We enjoyed dinner, heard some great music, and spent time together celebrating just before my birthday.
And I wouldn’t have wanted to miss it simply because it wasn’t the experience we’d first imagined.
I think there’s something worth remembering about our careers.
When an opportunity falls through, it’s reasonable to be disappointed. You invested in it for a reason.
But before deciding that nothing else will measure up, consider what you were hoping to gain and whether another opportunity might offer something equally worthwhile, even if it looks different.
Sometimes a second chance is worth taking on its own terms.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I reapply to a company that previously rejected me?
Yes, if a new position aligns with your qualifications and career goals. A previous rejection doesn’t necessarily mean the company wouldn’t consider you for another role. Hiring needs, leadership priorities, and candidate requirements can change. If you established a positive relationship during the original interview process, consider reconnecting with the recruiter or hiring manager.
How do I know whether a different career opportunity is worth pursuing?
Evaluate the opportunity against your current priorities rather than comparing it only with the position you originally wanted. Consider responsibilities, decision-making authority, compensation, organizational stability, leadership support, and long-term career development.
Before pursuing a different opportunity, it’s worth considering whether the position actually meets your needs. In my article on evaluating job opportunities and developing an effective job search strategy, I discuss why factors such as responsibilities, compensation, benefits, and organizational fit deserve attention before you invest time in the hiring process.
How can I maintain relationships after an unsuccessful interview?
Thank the people involved, express appreciation for their time, and leave the door open for future conversations. If you have a genuine reason to reconnect later, such as a relevant company development or a new position that fits your experience, reach out professionally. Avoid repeated messages that don’t offer a meaningful reason to reconnect.
Can a lateral career move be beneficial for an executive?
Yes, when it provides experience, responsibilities, or exposure that support a longer-term career objective. A lateral move into a new business function, industry, or operating environment may broaden an executive’s qualifications for future leadership opportunities. The value depends on the scope and growth opportunities, not the title alone.
What if I’m ready for a career change but don’t know what opportunities to pursue?
Many experienced professionals and executives have spent years building expertise in a particular role or industry. When it’s time to change, they may struggle to see how their experience could translate into opportunities beyond their current career path.
That’s one reason I’ve been developing Career Value Intelligence™ (CVI), a new program offered through Precision Resume Solutions.
CVI builds on my executive resume writing and career strategy work by helping professionals understand their transferable value, identify emerging career opportunities, and position themselves competitively as AI and other market forces reshape the workplace.
Whether you’re considering a career change, exploring opportunities in a different industry, or reassessing your professional direction, the starting point is understanding the value you’ve already developed and where it may be relevant next. If you want to learn more, please reach out.
About Clair Levy
Clair Levy, CPRW, CARW, CERM, CPC, is a Career Positioning Strategist and founder of Precision Resume Solutions. She helps executives and professionals uncover the value behind their experience and turn it into a compelling career story through strategic resumes, LinkedIn positioning, and career strategy. Her work helps clients clearly communicate their leadership, accomplishments, and business impact to hiring decision-makers.
Precision Resume Solutions
Where crafting your resume is an art of precision.
